With the Fundamentalist Mormons once again in the news, it is important to take a look at the practice that is highlighted by our "news" organizations --- polygamy. As this is an option chosen by over 50,000 Amercians, it is an important issue to address in a Spiritual Blog. How should those of us who are Spiritual see polygamous relationships? How should we treat those who are in one? Let's get rid of some of the dangerous myths that surround this uncommon, but growing, practice. (NOTE: Just as my writings on homosexual marriage, of which I approve, should not make one believe I am gay, one should not necessarily believe anything at all about my marital choices because of this article.)
Polygamy, the practice of being married to multiple husbands or wives, has gotten a “bad rap” from the fact that many practitioners of polygamy are either Mormon or Muslim. These are religions that Americans think are “weird,” and, as a result, see anything that is generally done by them to be “wrong.”
Because polygamy is mainly practiced by there unpopular religions, some very bad stereotypes have grown up around this practice. As ignorance leads to violence in America and Americans insist on believing that every single things has a “military solution,” here are some myths that should be busted on polygamy.
1). Polygamy is restricted to Mormons, Muslims and other weird religions. No, it isn’t. Many practitioners of polygamy are non-religious, and polygamy is practiced within many religious groups.
2). Women are forced or coerced into this practice. Nope. Sometimes it is the women who initiate it. While it might not make sense to you to want someone to share “your” man, it does make sense for many women.
3). Polygamy is bigamy. “Bigamy” is the practice of having two wives where one party, at least, is kept ignorant of the other. Because in polygamous marriages everyone tends to sleep with everyone else, it is unusual for them not to know about one another.
4). Polygamists wear prarie clothing and bonnets. Whatever. Some fundamentalist Mormons do. Most polygamists are indistinguishable from you or me.
5). Girls are forced into polygamous marriages very, very young. Very rarely and only in the Fundamentalist LDS Church organizations. Virtually all polygamous marriages are conducted between consenting adults.
6). Polygamy is exploitative of women. “Exploitation” is a code word for “feminists don’t like it.” Any form of marriage can certainly exploit men or women. Polygamous marriages sometimes wind up simply using women as objects. So do monogamous marriages. It is the people involved, not the marital form, that wind up exploitative. Feminists, Christians, “advocates” and so on should simply keep their noses out of people’s genitals. If a polygamous relationship is contracted between consenting adults, it is nobody’s business but theirs. It is condescending and insulting to the women involved to say that they’re involved in an exploitative relationship. Isn’t that for them to decide?
7). Polygamy complicates divorce, property settlements and child custody arrangements. Yes, it does. But, if memory serves, the law has handled social changes before. I know politicians are pretty brainless and those politicians who make laws very few working brain cells at all, but I’m sure something will be figured out.
8). Polygamy is against God’s Law! There are many answers to this accusation, including “who told you.” Not everyone accepts the Christian Bible as being the definitive rule book for people. However, even if one does accept the Bible (which I don’t) as a rule book for modern humans, polygamy is common in both Old and New Testaments. Polygamy is still not considered against Jewish Law, although most American Jews do not practice polygamy. The issue here is deeper, though. The issue is whether the belief system of a minority (Christians) in the world should be allowed to be crammed down the throats of those who do not hold that religion….or it that religion’s viewpoint should be permitted to be codified into law. My answer to both is “hell, no!” If I’m not a Christian, I shouldn’t have to be bound by their laws or follow their Bible. Making it civil law, in my opinion, violates the First Amendment to the Constitution of the United States.
9). Polygamists marry off their teenaged daughters to older men. Some certainly do. These people deserve to be jailed. This is a clear violation of the laws regarding underage sexual relationships. If such occur, off to the hoosegow. But this has absolutely nothing to do with polygamy per se. It is like saying that, because so many Roman Catholic priests are pedophiles, that the Roman Catholic Priesthood (also a marriage option) should be prohibited. As always, the people who are “sexual moralists” blur and confuse any argument by bringing in extraneous issues. This is certainly one of them.
10). Polygamists belong to a cult. Some polygamists are involved with the Fundamentalist Latter Day Saints Church. Many others are Islamic. But this lifestyle cuts across all lines. Like “exploitative,” “cult” is one of those words that is applied to something that some groups don’t like. The word “cult” is applied to any religious or spiritual option that Christians don’t like, but isn’t large enough to have a press department.
11). Polygamists live in compounds and refuse to have their children educated in public schools. Again, some do, some don’t. I suspect that most polygamists would be much more comfortable about sending their children to public schools if the public schools had not, in the last couple of decades, adopted a policy of interrogating children as to the sexual habits of their parents, and sending social services out if those sexual habits don’t exactly match the things society completely approves of.
But most polygamists don't live in compounds. Those that live in community (“compounds” is another “trigger” word that people who oppose them use) don’t necessarily keep themselves from the outside world. And, even if they do, that is their Constitutional right. Isn’t it funny how we go after someone who actually exercises his or her rights under the Constitution?
As to public schooling….I wouldn’t send any kids of mine to today’s public school, although my daughter went from Middle School on to one. They messed up her mind with their crap. I want my kids of this marriage, when they are of age, educated at a private school where they’ll actually get an education rather than indoctrination into the belief systems of a very sick society.
12). Women in polygamous relationships have no where else to go. This is simply absurd. While those who are Fundamentalist of any stripe tend, as a group, to be incredibly uneducated and ignorant to several decimal places (like Sarah Palin), I know polygamous relationships where the wives have graduate degrees, successful careers, and even most of the money in the relationship. They have plenty of other places to go. They just choose to stay with their spouses…all 2, 3, 4 or 5 (or more) of them. And being poor and ignorant may be looked down on in America, but it doesn’t mean that those women in polygamous relationships who are poor and ignorant are also unable to get out of that relationship if they wish. The fact that so many have done so bespeaks the fact that leaving is quite possible. There are many support groups for women. It is much more difficult for men to leave an abusive relationship.
13). Polygamous relationships are abusive. Just like any other relationship, some are. Most aren’t. As always, though, when Christians don’t like something they start the propaganda machine. The abused women will be trotted out and displayed, made to look as pathetic as possible, and tell very sad stories. By doing the exact same thing anyone could make a case against marriage, homosexuality, heterosexuality, dating, cohabitation, etc. One could even make a claim that football is “bad for children.” The Christians are some great propagandists. It is too bad that so many people fall for their propaganda.
14). There is a higher instance of child abuse in polygamist families than in non-polygamous families. There is no evidence for this, and no statistics to support this.
15). Polygamists believe oppressive religions. Yes, some of them might. AND????? The right of people to believe any damned fool thing they wish was one of the pillars of founding this country. The drumbeat against certain religions is simply part of the slow and steady Christian plan to turn America into an Evangelical Theocracy. I don’t want to live under such a system, and I hope neither do you.
16). Polygamy is about sex, sex, sex for the incredibly lustful man who collects wives. Well, in one sense, marriage is about sex, too. You don’t see people protesting because newlyweds do everything possible to have a week or two of uninterrupted sexual fun called a “Honeymoon.”
But most polygamy is not about sex. In fact, for a variety of logistical and psychological reasons, the man who has multiple wives probably gets less sex than the one who is monogamous. Americans have very dirty minds.
Most polygamy is about love, something Americans don’t like much. Most sister-wives are best friends and see themselves as sisters. In non-religious polygamy, the wives are often sexual with one another as well as being sexual with their co-husband.
Any objection to this is, once again, based on Christian beliefs which they have no right to cram down our throats, either by their incessant preaching or by passing laws based on their intolerance and lies.
Most polygamists are solid family people who have a great deal of love to share. Virtually all polygamy is consensual between consenting adults. While those two beasts, the Church and the State, wish to interfere with people’s rights regarding sex, the Supreme Court has mostly said that they can’t. Most polygamists would love for a case to be filed soon, as the composition of the Court is changing dramatically in the next couple of years under a Democratic administration. It is likely that sexual privacy would trump “Onward Christian Soldiers.”
As there has not been a successful polygamy qua polygamy case filed in over 50 years, however, this sounds like a non-starting issue for the right wingnuts, Christians and Muslims. Better luck next time.
Now, most people aren’t in a polygamous relationship. So why should you care what the government does to some fringe people who want to love more than one person? Well, there are several reasons you must care. First, we all lose every time the government and the Christians make their unholy alliance and interfere in our lives. We must break the tie between the Evangelical and Roman Churches and the State. Those of us who do not want these people ruling our lives pay taxes, fight in uniform and so on as well. It is a horrible precedent to allow one religion or religious coalition to have influence in the government. It is even bad precedent for the Christians as well. We are protecting them, too, by creating and enforcing an incredibly strong barrier between Church and State. After all, the next group wanting control could be Muslim or Atheist.
The second reason you must care is that it could be you next. As Pastor Neimoller said,
First they came for the Jews
and I did not speak out because I was not a Jew.
Then they came for the Communists
and I did not speak out because I was not a Communist.
Then they came for the trade unionists
and I did not speak out
because I was not a trade unionist.
Then they came for me
and there was no one left to speak out for me.
If we do not speak out for the polygamists, gays, lesbians and others in alternate sexual relationships, when they try to regulate what we do in the bedroom, with whom we may have sex, and so on, there will be no one left to speak out. The right to sexual expression and sexual privacy, in whatever configuration we wish, is one of the most basic of human rights. We must not allow Christians and the State in unholy alliance to continue to interfere with it.
The third and final reason that you must care is the we must forever break the control of the tyranny of the majority and the tyranny of religion over the behavior of an obstensibly free people. As long as the superstitions of the past and the coercive power of the State are joined in unholy matrimony and control this most private and personal of activities, we are enslaved to the State….and the Church. For those who choose to be under the rule of the Church, this is fine for them. But many of us choose not to be under the rule of superstition and religion. For those who make the latter choice….freedom from religion is essential, or we are not truly free.
Freedom.
J.
New Post
-
There is a new post on www.lovingspirituality.com, my new home for Spiritual
Mastery Secrets. Please go there and read it. This one is on Soul Traps.
3 weeks ago
